Raising Gifted Kids: What Parents Want to Know #5
- Julie Church
- 2 days ago
- 4 min read
When Effort Feels Like Failure
By Danielle Sullivan, Ed.D.
“I can’t do this.” “It’s too hard.” “I’m never doing this again.”
You’ve heard the words—or maybe you’ve seen the tears before the words even come. Your child shuts down,rips up the paper, or walks away. It’s heartbreaking to watch, especially when you know how capable they are.
For many gifted kids, effort feels like failure.
They’re so used to things coming easily that the first stumble feels like proof something is wrong.
You watch them meltdown over a worksheet, a piano lesson, or even a board game, and you wonder, How can someone so bright be so hard on themselves?
Why This Happens
Gifted learners often grow up praised for their quick thinking and correct answers. Over time, they begin to link “smart” with “easy.” So when something isn’t easy, they panic.
That panic can sound like:
“I can’t do it.”
“This is stupid.”
“I’m done.”
And it can look like:
Crumpled papers, slammed doors, or perfectionist tears.
Avoiding new challenges altogether.
Pretending not to care because caring feels risky.
But this doesn’t mean they’re lazy or dramatic—it means their identity as a learner is still developing. They’re beginning to learn that intelligence isn’t about being right the first time; it’s about having the courage and persistence to keep going when it’s not easy, to stay curious even when things feel uncertain.
What’s Really Going On
Underneath the frustration is fear:
Fear of not being good enough.
Fear of losing the “smart kid” label.
Fear of disappointing you, their teachers, or even themselves.
When kids confuse effort with inability, they miss the joy of learning—the messy part that builds real confidence. Instead of seeing struggle as progress, they see it as proof they’ve failed and begin to avoid challenges that might stretch them. They choose what feels safe over what helps them grow. But when they learn to stay with the hard parts, they start to realize that effort is evidence of learning, not a lack of talent—and that confidence doesn’t come from being perfect; it comes from persistence.
What Parents Can Do
Even when we understand what’s happening, watching our child fall apart over frustration can feel helpless. The goal isn’t to remove the struggle—it’s to help them see mistakes as information, not identity.
In Finland, teachers often respond to mistakes in three steps that parents can borrow at home:
Summarize the moment: Name what you saw without judgment. “I noticed you got frustrated when your drawing didn’t turn out how you hoped.”
Normalize it through connection: Share a time you made a similar mistake. “That happens to me, too—once I ruined a recipe because I misread the directions.”
Offer choices for moving forward: “Would you like to start again, change your approach, or take a break first?”
This simple pattern teaches kids that mistakes aren’t something to hide—they’re something to learn from.
Here are other ways to strengthen that same message:
Name the pattern without shame.
“It looks like you’re feeling frustrated because it’s not easy right away. That happens to everyone when they’re learning something new.”
Praise process, not perfection.
Instead of “You’re so smart,” try “I love how you kept trying different ways to solve it.”
Share your own struggle stories.
Talk about something you had to work hard for—learning a skill, fixing a mistake, starting a new job.
Create safe practice zones.
Let them experiment in low-pressure spaces—drawing, coding, cooking, building—where mistakes are part of the fun.
Use small steps to rebuild confidence.
Break large tasks into manageable pieces. Celebrate progress, not just completion.
Model calm when they melt down.
Take a breath before responding. A calm adult teaches emotional regulation more than any lecture can.
End the day with a reflection question.
“What’s one thing you had to work for today—and what did you learn from it?”
Try This Together
Learning to handle frustration isn’t something kids do alone—it grows through how we talk, play, and connect as a family.
Watch, listen, or remember together.Share a story, short video, or even a family memory of someone practicing or persevering—a grandparent learning a new skill, an athlete training, an artist improving. What do they have in common? They all kept going.
Turn ordinary life into practice time.Invite your child to help cook a meal, repair something, garden, or play a simple game. Point out how trying again makes a difference.
Celebrate persistence, not perfection.Try developing a weekly moment—during dinner, a walk, or on a ride home—where each person shares one thing they practiced or improved, big or small.
Use your own words and traditions.In some families, reflection happens through stories; in others, through humor, prayer, or quiet time. What matters is showing that learning takes time—and that everyone keeps learning.
The Bottom Line
Gifted kids don’t need to be rescued from frustration—they need to see that effort isn’t proof they’ve failed. It’s how they grow.
And parents need reminders, too: it’s okay if you don’t have the perfect words or the perfect plan. This journey isn’t theirs alone—you’re learning right alongside them. When you stay calm, stay close, and keep showing up, you model what persistence really looks like.
Each time your family navigates the tears, the doubts, and the do-overs together, you’re showing that growth is a family value. Every mistake becomes a shared lesson, every recovery a reminder that confidence grows from trying again.
Together, we turn struggle into strength—and effort into confidence.
✨ Parent to Parent: How does your child react when something doesn’t come easily? What helps them keep going? Share in the comments—you may give another parent the words they need today.
Comments